Subletting: What are the Pros and Cons?

Subletting is a rental arrangement where a tenant (the original tenant) leases all or part of their rented space to another person (the subtenant) for a specific period. The original tenant becomes the sublessor, and the subtenant pays rent to them, not the landlord. Subletting can be a practical solution for tenants who need to temporarily leave their rented space, such as for travel, work, or personal reasons, but don’t want to break their lease or pay for an empty apartment.

To sublet your rental space, review your lease agreement, notify your landlord, find a subtenant, prepare a legally binding sublease agreement, collect a security deposit, conduct a walkthrough, collect rent, and maintain communication. It’s crucial to adhere to your original lease agreement, including payment methods and due dates, and ensure the subletting period is set. This process ensures a smooth transition and ensures a smooth transition for both parties involved.

Remember, subletting is a significant responsibility, and you are still ultimately responsible for the property and any lease violations committed by the subtenant. Be sure to familiarize yourself with your local laws and consult with a legal professional if you have any questions or concerns.

What are the Pros?

Subletting can have several benefits for tenants, including:

  1. Reducing costs: Subletting can help tenants offset the cost of rent and utilities by sharing the expenses with a subtenant. This can be especially helpful for tenants who are struggling to make ends meet or who are facing unexpected expenses.
  2. Financial flexibility: Subletting can provide tenants with financial flexibility by allowing them to earn extra income or reduce their expenses. This can be particularly useful for tenants who are self-employed, freelancers, or students with irregular income.
  3. Maintaining the lease: Subletting can help tenants maintain their lease and avoid breaking it, which can result in penalties or legal consequences. This can be especially important for tenants who need to leave their rented space temporarily, such as for work or travel.
  4. Securing the property: Subletting can help tenants secure their property by ensuring that it is occupied and looked after while they are away. This can help prevent theft, vandalism, or other damage to the property.

However, it’s important to note that subletting also comes with some risks and challenges, such as finding a reliable subtenant, complying with lease agreements and local laws, and managing the subtenant’s behavior and responsibilities. Before subletting, tenants should carefully review their lease agreement, consult with their landlord, and take steps to protect themselves and their property.

On the other hand, what are the Cons?

While subletting can offer benefits, it also presents some challenges and potential drawbacks, including:

  1. Legal complexities: Subletting can involve navigating complex legal issues, such as lease agreements, local laws, and tenant rights. Tenants must ensure they are in compliance with all relevant regulations and obtain any necessary permissions or approvals from their landlord.
  2. Liability issues: As the original tenant, you may still be held responsible for any damages, unpaid rent, or lease violations committed by the subtenant. This can potentially lead to financial and legal consequences if the subtenant fails to fulfill their obligations.
  3. Finding responsible subtenants: It can be challenging to find reliable and responsible subtenants who will respect the property, pay rent on time, and follow the rules. Conducting thorough background checks, interviews, and reference checks can help mitigate this risk, but there is still no guarantee of finding an ideal subtenant.
  4. Privacy concerns: Subletting involves sharing living space with someone else, which can lead to privacy issues. The original tenant may feel uncomfortable with the subtenant’s presence or have concerns about the security of their personal belongings.

To address these potential drawbacks, tenants should carefully consider the decision to sublet, communicate openly with their landlord, and take steps to protect their interests. This may include creating a comprehensive sublease agreement, collecting a security deposit, and maintaining open lines of communication with both the landlord and subtenant throughout the subletting period.

Is it wise to engage in subletting?

Engaging in subletting can be a wise decision in certain situations, but it is not without its risks and challenges. Before deciding to sublet, consider the following factors:

  1. Lease agreement and landlord approval: Review your lease agreement to determine if subletting is allowed and if there are any specific requirements or restrictions. Additionally, seek your landlord’s approval and ensure you are in compliance with their policies and procedures.
  2. Subletting laws and regulations: Familiarize yourself with the local laws and regulations regarding subletting. Some areas have specific rules and requirements that must be followed, such as obtaining a permit or limiting the subletting period.
  3. Trustworthy subtenants: Finding responsible and reliable subtenants can be a challenge. Conduct thorough background checks, interviews, and reference checks to help ensure you are selecting a subtenant who will respect the property and fulfill their obligations.
  4. Communication and documentation: Maintain open lines of communication with both your landlord and subtenant throughout the subletting period. Document all agreements, changes, and interactions in writing to protect yourself and avoid misunderstandings.
  5. Potential financial and legal risks: Understand that as the original tenant, you may still be held responsible for any damages, unpaid rent, or lease violations committed by the subtenant. Consider the potential financial and legal risks involved and take steps to mitigate them, such as collecting a security deposit and creating a comprehensive sublease agreement.
  6. Privacy and living arrangements: Subletting involves sharing living space with someone else, which can impact your privacy and living arrangements. Consider if you are comfortable with this arrangement and if it aligns with your lifestyle and preferences.

Ultimately, the decision to engage in subletting depends on your specific circumstances and comfort level with the associated risks and challenges. If done responsibly and with proper planning, subletting can be a beneficial arrangement that provides financial flexibility and helps you maintain your lease while you are away.

What does the law say about subletting?

A sublease agreement is a contract between the original tenant and the subtenant, outlining the terms and conditions of the subletting arrangement. It should be in writing and signed by both parties to ensure clarity and protection for all involved. The original tenant remains responsible for the obligations under the original lease, such as paying rent, maintaining the property, and adhering to the terms of the lease agreement. The subtenant is responsible for fulfilling the obligations outlined in the sublease agreement.

Legal recourse may be available if either party fails to fulfill their obligations, such as eviction or financial damages. Local regulations may also apply, such as restrictions on the number of times a unit can be sublet in a year in San Francisco. Familiarizing oneself with the local laws and regulations that may apply to your situation is advisable.

To ensure compliance with the law and protect your interests, it is advisable to consult with a legal professional or tenant’s rights organization familiar with the laws in your jurisdiction. They can provide guidance on your specific situation and help navigate any legal complexities that may arise from subletting.


In conclusion, subletting can be a viable option for tenants who need to temporarily leave their rented space and want to avoid breaking their lease or paying for an empty apartment. However, it is essential to understand the legal and practical considerations involved in subletting, such as lease agreements, landlord approval, finding responsible subtenants, and addressing privacy concerns.

If you are considering subletting your rental property and need assistance with property management, Eagle Property Management can help. As a trusted property management company, Eagle Property Management offers a range of services to both landlords and tenants, including lease management, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and tenant screening. Their experienced team can help you navigate the complexities of subletting while ensuring a smooth and hassle-free experience for all parties involved.

Request a Property Management Quote