How Landlords Deal with Difficult Tenants?

Dealing with difficult tenants is important for landlords and property managers, as they can cause problems by failing to pay rent, causing property damage, or breaking property restrictions.

Landlords should be calm, objective, and rational when dealing with them, and keep written records of everything to have evidence in case of legal disputes.

Landlords should teach tenants how they should treat them and try to get them on their side, and they may need to ask the terrible tenants to leave or begin the eviction process. It is also recommended to hire a professional property management agency if dealing with difficult tenants becomes too challenging.

Understanding Difficult Tenants

Identifying Different Types of Difficult Tenants

Identifying and dealing with difficult tenants is important for landlords and property managers to effectively deal with them. Common types of difficult tenants includes the following:

  • Non-Paying Tenants: These tenants are often the most frustrating to deal with as they fail to pay rent on time or at all.
  • Destructive Tenants: These tenants may cause damage to the property, either intentionally or through neglect.
  • Disruptive Tenants: These tenants may disturb the peace and quiet of other tenants or neighbors through excessive noise, parties, or other disruptive behavior.
  • Violent or Threatening Tenants: These tenants may pose a physical threat to other tenants, neighbors, or property managers.
  • Uncooperative Tenants: These tenants may refuse to comply with lease terms or requests from property managers, making it difficult to resolve issues or maintain a positive landlord-tenant relationship.

Landlords should have a strong lease agreement in place and screen tenants before renting to them. They should also be proactive in addressing issues with tenants and consider hiring a professional property management agency if necessary.

Impact of Difficult Tenants on Property Management

Dealing with difficult tenants can significantly impact property management, causing increased workload, property damage, increased vacancy rates, legal issues, and reputation damage. Difficult tenants may cause intentional or neglectful damage to the property, resulting in additional maintenance and repair costs.

Common reasons behind tenant difficulties include non-payment of rent, property damage, violation of lease terms, disruptive behavior, demanding behavior, illegal activities, late payments, complaints and demands, broken appliances and fixtures, and holes in walls and stained flooring.

To minimize the impact of difficult tenants on property management, landlords should thoroughly screen tenants before renting to them, have a strong lease agreement in place, and be proactive in addressing issues with tenants.

Common Problems You May Encounter with a Difficult Tenant

  1. Late or non-payment of rent: This is a common issue that can cause financial strain for landlords
  2. Property damage: Some tenants may not care for the property as they should, while others may make unauthorized “improvements” that can be costly for landlords
  3. Noise complaints: Noisy tenants can be a nuisance to other tenants and neighbors and can lead to legal action if not addressed
  4. Rule violations: Tenants who violate lease agreements or housing laws can cause legal trouble for landlords
  5. Maintenance issues: Maintenance-related issues can negatively impact the rental experience for tenants if left unaddressed for too long.

Key Tips For Handling Difficult Tenants

  1. Communicate effectively. Good communication is key to resolving conflicts with difficult tenants. Be clear, concise, and respectful in your communication, and try to listen to their concerns and needs.
  2. Stay calm and Professional. Avoid getting emotional or confrontational, as this can escalate the situation and make it more difficult to resolve.
  3. Document everything. Keep detailed records of all interactions with difficult tenants, including emails, phone calls, and in-person conversations. This can help protect you in case of legal disputes.
  4. Be proactive. Address issues as soon as they arise, rather than waiting for them to escalate. This can help prevent small problems from turning into larger ones.
  5. Enforce the lease agreement. If a tenant is violating the terms of the lease agreement, take action to enforce it. This may include issuing warnings, fines, or even eviction notices if necessary.
  6. Seek legal advice if necessary. If you are unsure how to handle a difficult tenant or if the situation has escalated to the point of legal action, seek advice from a qualified attorney.
  7. Consider Mediation. In some cases, mediation may be a useful tool for resolving disputes with difficult tenants. A neutral third party can help facilitate communication and find a mutually acceptable solution.

Advantages of Establishing Effective Communication

Effective communication is crucial in property management for maintaining successful relationships with tenants and avoiding negative consequences. Clear and timely communication can lead to increased tenant satisfaction, improved property maintenance, and timely rent payments. Below are some of the advantages of establishing effective communication on difficult tenants.

  • Improved Tenant Satisfaction: Effective communication can help improve tenant satisfaction by addressing their concerns and needs in a timely and effective manner.
  • Increased Efficiency: Effective communication can help property managers identify and address issues more quickly
  • Better Problem-Solving: By listening carefully to tenants’ concerns and feedback, property managers can better understand their needs and concerns. This can lead to more effective problem-solving and improved tenant satisfaction.
  • Improved Reputation: By establishing effective communication with tenants, property managers can improve their reputation and attract new tenants.

Developing a professional and respectful approach, utilizing written communication channels, and actively listening with empathy are essential for effective communication. Poor communication can lead to issues such as loss of business, negative reviews, and tenant turnover.

To improve tenant communication, property managers should prioritize clear, consistent, timely, and empathetic communication to build positive relationships with tenants and improve retention rates. It is also important to establish open lines of communication, utilize technology to facilitate communication and implement a communication strategy for effective team collaboration.

Implementing a Comprehensive Tenant Screening Process

A. Importance of thorough tenant screening:

  • Tenant screening is a standardized process that validates information about tenants.
  • It is highly important to investigate tenants to ensure they are reliable and trustworthy.
  • Tenant screening can help distinguish quality tenants from problematic ones.

B. Key elements of a screening process:

  • Conducting background checks, verifying employment and income, and checking references.
  • Putting rental criteria in writing and offering it to applicants before they fill out an application.
  • Treating each application consistently by establishing a documented procedure.
  • Checking rental and credit history.
  • Writing a clear and proper lease agreement.

C. Legal considerations and fair housing guidelines:

  • Tenant screening must comply with fair housing laws to avoid discrimination against protected classes.
  • Screening criteria should be consistent for all applicants to avoid accusations of steering.
  • Landlords should create a written rental policy that outlines their tenant screening criteria.

Implementing Effective Conflict Resolution Strategies

A. Dealing with conflicts promptly and professionally:

  • Promptly addressing conflicts can prevent them from escalating.
  • Using respectful communication and avoiding threats or provocative moves can help de-escalate tensions.
  • Engaging with the other person respectfully, listening closely to their grievances, and exploring creative ways to address them can help resolve conflicts.

B. Mediation and negotiation techniques:

  • Negotiation strategies such as tradeoffs and using time to your advantage can help parties mend their partnership and avoid litigation.
  • Mediation is a viable option for creating a structure for conflict resolution in an unbiased manner.

C. Legal considerations and seeking professional advice when necessary:

  • Conflict resolution should be done in a way that complies with legal considerations and fair treatment of all parties involved.
  • Seeking professional advice, such as from a mediator or attorney, may be necessary in some cases.


The most important details in this text are that landlords and property managers must master the art of dealing with difficult tenants by implementing effective communication strategies, conducting thorough tenant screenings, setting clear expectations with lease agreements, and utilizing conflict resolution techniques.

Additionally, it is important to stay informed about local landlord-tenant laws and regulations, document lease violations, and take appropriate action when necessary. Eagle Property Management offers expert advice and solutions for property management challenges, such as tenant screening, lease agreements, conflict resolution, and eviction processes.

Visit Eagle Property Management today and unlock the tools and knowledge you need to handle challenging tenant situations like a true professional.

Request a Property Management Quote